Nurses feel they must accept violence as part of their job, study shows

We came across this most interesting, recent South Australian study into violence at the Lyell McEwin Hopsital, which found that nurses do not always report [violent] incidents because they feel nothing will be done, or that they will be victimised by their managers!  In my opinion, as a violently assaulted nurse, I believe that violence against nurses should be the same as violence against police. Zero tolerance!

Nurses feel they must accept violence as part of their job, new research shows

A study into violence at the Lyell McEwin Hospital found nurses do not always report incidents because they feel nothing will be done, or they would be victimised by managers.

They also feel ill-equipped and untrained to deal with the ongoing violence.

Clinical nurse and University of Adelaide masters student April Stanley-Banks conducted the study after being exposed to violence during a decade in the LMH emergency department.

There was a culture that violence is part of the job, she said.

“Although they had a zero-tolerance policy towards violence in place at the department, it was something that I could see wasn’t addressing the situation enough to prevent it.”

She has been threatened, verbally and physically abused and once had her jaw displaced when a patient punched her. Her study found that nurses had felt betrayed by management.

“There are many reasons that nurses don’t report and they extend from a belief of `what is the use’ because nothing is going to be done or being victimised if they do report it,” she said.

In the study, she reports: “All (nurses) held an unprecedented belief that violence in the ED was ignored by management and felt insulted and unsupported by unevaluated efforts made to address it despite its escalation.”

“All nurses agreed that they felt they should shut up and put up with violent patients and take personal responsibility for safety,” it says in the study.

Incidents included those involving weapons such as knives and, in one case, a sawn-off rifle.

The nurses felt they would lose their registration if they did not develop a resilience.

Australian Nursing and Midwifery Federation state secretary Elizabeth Dabars said nurses must be able to feel supported in reporting any violent incident.

Northern Adelaide Local Health Network chief executive Margot Mains said the reporting of aggressive incidents or threats against staff is actively encouraged so they could be fully investigated.

“We would be happy to talk to any employee who feels they may not have received adequate support so we can investigate and continue to improve our processes,” she said.

Opposition Health spokesman Martin Hamilton-Smith, however, said that the work was further evidence an independent inquiry into hospital violence was now essential.”

[Source: http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/news/south-australia/study-finds-abuse-by-patients-considered-part-of-job/story-e6frea83-1226426655360]

Having been the victim of a – preventable-senseless violent physical assault myself, on a night shift in an intensive care unit, and having lost all function in my right, dominant arm as a consequence (and my career), I believe that nobody should have to accept or expect violence to be a part of their job.

Anyone guilty of expressing or displaying  deliberate (controlled) violence towards a nurse should be held accountable before the courts for their actions. Violence is totally unacceptable in all forms.And the people (i.e managers, even doctors and supervisors) who are reckless enough to allow sheer and foreseeable endangerment of nurses should also be accountable for their negligence and their actions punished!

Anyone carrying out their duties in relation to employment  should expect the right of reasonable co-operation. Anyone failing to co-operate should be removed.

I have zero tolerance for any form of violence against nurses (and any workers) and it is high time that this “culture” is investigated and rectified as soon as possible, before any more damage is done.

 

Related post:

Patients brandishing knives, head butting nurses, spitting at doctors and throwing urine on hospital staff are among daily incidents in the state’s health system…

 

Shortlink: http://wp.me/p1MA9G-2VD

 

About WorkcoverVictim

I was assaulted by a large patient whilst working as a nurse . I underwent numerous major shoulder reconstructions and suffered near fatal complications. I am left with an extremely painful and irreparable dominant arm. This site was born out of my sheer frustration, anger and grief regarding the workcover system where all is not made clear, where the waters are very murky, and when the chips are down, the very people who are responsible for duty of care and support simply choose to ignore you, the injured worker. I dedicate this site to all injured workers who have been abused by the adversarial workcover compensation system. May they never give up, may they fight like warriors for their legitimate rights, and -most importantly- may they hold onto their dignity, self-respect, self-esteem and sanity; and may they WIN!

, , ,

One Response to Nurses feel they must accept violence as part of their job, study shows

  1. John McPhilbin July 17, 2012 at 2:46 PM #

    It has got to make you wonder – nurses face high rates of bullying from cooworkers and superiors and from violent patients. Being a carer shouldn’t equate to being a punching bag, yet here it is, nurses are.

Leave a Reply

Attach a file Uploading File types: jpg, png, gif,doc,docx,pdf,ppt,txt,wmv,flv,rtf,mp4,mp3,swf,zip, Max size: 500Mbytes, Max count: 3